Friday, January 9, 2015

A CURSORY GLANCE AT ON-STREET PARKING: THE WAY FORWARD!


1.1  Introduction:

The issue of transportation development is at the heart of every nation. Due to economic activities in city centers, various spaces have been created outside and along streets as a parking facility for automobiles. Currently, traffic congestion and parking problems in urban areas are getting out of hand in many developing countries. In Ghana, decision makers in most cases favour removal of on-street parking from major arterials. They argue that this action might increase road capacity and improve safety. On the other hand, arguments for allowing on-street parking have traditionally been based on the potential benefits to local merchants. Innes et al (1990) agrees with the latter by stating that accessibility and parking convenience are among major factors that affect shoppers' destination choices. 


Recently, city authorities in Ghana face challenges in the areas of parking infrastructure availability, parking demand, safety problems of vehicles and pedestrians, time and turnover, pricing for parking and maintenance of infrastructure. These and many other challenges make on-street parking a major ‘headache’ and therefore call for answers in terms of its management. The key objective of this exposé is to expound some effects of on-street parking and identify measures to manage on-street parking.

1.2 Effects of On-Street Parking:

There are benefits of on-street parking. Litman (2006) explained that aside the convenience, on-street parking is said to be one of the best ways to provide shared parking. It is thought to be in higher demand than the alternative off-street spaces and considered more efficient as a result of higher occupancy rates. For that reason, pricing proponents such as Shoup suggest setting the highest fees for the on-street spaces (Shoup, 2004). During one of Los Angeles’ on-street parking bans, the city started to find a noticeable decline in retail business (Jakle and Sculle, 2004). Without the on-street parking spaces, the convenience factor appeared to diminish and people shopped elsewhere.

On-street parking is also considered to be more efficient with regard to land use because on-street spaces do not require access lanes or driveways (Litman, 2006). Comparing the amount of land required for an off-street surface lot to that needed for an on-street parking space, Litman (2006) and Shoup (2004) both estimate that the access lanes and driveways to the off-street parking lots is more than double the amount of land devoted to parking. In addition, landscaping requirements generally account for adding another 10% to 15% of total land area to a parking lot (Litman, 2006).

There is a strong argument that convenient parking fosters economic growth and development. The placement of on-street parking near businesses and retail uses improves accessibility and convenience to customers and has been used as a strategy for revitalization of central business districts and attraction of renewed consumer patronage to downtown areas. A number of behavioural studies cited availability of parking as a factor affecting shoppers' travel decisions. For example, an analysis of shoppers' behavioural patterns used data from Fredericton, Canada and a binary logit disaggregate behavioural model to determine the major factors affecting shoppers' destination choices. The study revealed that the availability of parking and the accessibility to the shopping area were among the most important factors in trip decision-making (Innes et al, 1990).

On-street parking is a potential traffic calming measure. Urban planners promoting new urbanism and neo-traditional street designs, as well as advocates of livable and walkable communities and proponents of traffic calming all agree that the use of on-street parking can have many benefits. On-street parking is viewed as part of the strategy to reduce motorists speeding through increased side friction. Replacement of traffic lanes by parking lanes, or reduction of traffic lane widths to allow for on-street parking show reduction in motorists speeds and better compliance with posted speed limits. Moreover, alternating of on-street parking from one side of the road to another can create a chicane-like effect in residential settings. According to Ewing (1999), this technique is a proven traffic calming measure that can reduce travel speed and result in benefits similar to those of actual chicanes at a fraction of the cost.
Among other benefits, properly designed and placed on-street parking is viewed as a means to create conditions where large vehicles can use the added space at intersections to improve their effective turning radii. Sight lines are preserved at intersections with 30- to 50-foot parking setbacks from intersecting legs (Burden, 1999). 

On-street parking cannot be said to have only positive effects. Some of the negative effects are that, firstly, substitution of a road lane by a parking lane has an important impact on capacity and a potential effect on traffic operations. This is expected to be the case when on-street parking is introduced to the state trunk line system. On-street parking limits street capacity in two ways. Firstly, it pre-empts lanes that otherwise would be used by moving traffic. Secondly, parking and un-parking maneuvers frequently reduce the capacity of the adjacent lanes. Even a single vehicle parked within a curb lane can effectively close the lane to moving traffic. At higher speeds and during periods of heavy traffic movement, on-street parking is incompatible with arterial street service and should not be permitted (AASHTO, 1994).

Furthermore, emergency vehicle access in some way is affected by on-street parking. On-street parking constitutes a serious emergency hazard wherever cars block fire hydrants or obstruct fire apparatus. Parking restrictions in the vicinity of fire stations and fire hydrants are essential public safety requirements. When placement of on-street parking is necessary or desirable, available street space must meet requirements for emergency vehicle maneuvering and fire hose laying (Chick, 1996).

1.3 Regulatory Measures for On-Street Parking:

Since on-street parking is a vital component especially in economic growth and development in a commercial area but at the same time can cause havoc if not properly managed, there is the need to put in place some regulatory mechanisms. On-street parking management approaches include: pricing actions, marketing initiatives, and enforcement and adjudication programs (U.S. Department of Transportation, 1980). On-street parking is controlled (paid) when it is required as a parking management measure (Palmer and Ferris, 2010). That is, on-street parking pricing in is done so that most drivers park there for short term errands while parking for long hours is to be done off-street. 

On-street parking restrictions are effective only if they are properly enforced.  Thus, strong and active enforcement and adjudication programs are essential. On-street parking enforcement should be considered as a sub-system of the total parking management system that aims at improving use of existing parking supply, increasing revenues, improving public and traffic safety, and enhancing quality of life and business climate. Enforcement tactics, such as aggressive ticketing, towing, and booting illegally on-street parked vehicles, have been used in many communities around the nation (U.S. Department of Transportation, 1981).

When talking about parking there is no way the issue of parking meter can be overlooked. Parking meter is an instrument where money is placed before using a parking facility and this could be manual or automatic. This metered parking is normally for short term but it all depends on the parking charges which will determine whether users can afford to pay extra charges or not thence time for parking (short or long) can be defined. 
 
The strategies for managing on-street parking are enormous and cut across other parking needs simply because they work hand in hand to give an effective and efficient parking management. According to Litman (2006), the following regulatory mechanisms can be put in place for effective and efficient on-street parking management:
  •  Increase enforcement of regulations that are friendly and fair during some periods of the day.
  •  Reduce on-street parking time limits. This will increase turnover and also free up the area for other users to access it.
  • Encourage businesses to share parking facilities. For example, an office building can use the parking spaces during the day and for the cinema hall also to use it during the night.
  • Encourage the use of alternative modes. Example, park and ride where people will park and join shuttle service to the commercial area.
  • Establish high standards for parking facility design, including aesthetic features and user and environmental safety.
On-street parking space is a scarce resource, thus, priorities for its use should be established in the public interest. Managing scarce parking resources means determining if and how parking should be regulated, ensuring adequate compliance with regulations, and following up on those who do not comply. 

Parking management policies generate a variety of quantitative and qualitative impacts related to transportation, development, the environment, neighborhood, and revenue that should be carefully considered. For example, increasing short-term on-street parking while decreasing long-term parking may attract additional short-term parkers and constrain long-term parking, promote transit patronage among long-term parkers, improve highway level of service and air quality, reduce energy consumption, and promote economic growth through increased retail sales. Depending upon the actual new mix of short- and long-term parkers, parking revenue may either increase or decrease.

1.4 CONCLUSION:
On-street parking space represents a valuable resource. Thus, on-street parking is very important in every society especially where commercial activities go on along the road. This is because where on-street parking spaces are provided, motorists can park their vehicles and carry out their shopping activities conveniently. However, on-street parking if not properly managed can cause congestion especially when vehicles are parked at illegal places on the road. This can pose safety problems to all road users since moving vehicles can crash with the illegally parked vehicles or knock pedestrians down when crossing the road due to the blockage of their view by the parked vehicles. The congestion created by the illegally parked vehicles on the street and other factors can have multiplier effects such as delays to people, freight and vehicles, high operating cost of vehicles, pollution, environmental degradation, casualties and accidents, loss of productive hours, low economic development and low standard of living in the long run.

On the other hand, when congestion management strategies are put in place such as strict enforcement of laws, road pricing, parking pricing, road capacity expansion, transit improvement and rideshare programs, the negative effects of on-street parking will be reduced to the barest minimum. When this is done, the road will be free from heavy congestion and normal activities of people can be carried out with ease.

Reference:
AASHTO (1994): A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets. Washington, D.C.
Burden, D. et al. (1999):  Street  Design  Guidelines  for Healthy  Neighborhoods. Florida, Center for Livable Communities, High Springs.
Chick, C. (1996): On-Street Parking: A Guide to Practice. London, U.K, Landor Publishing.
Ewing, R. (1990):  Traffic  Calming - State  of  the  Practice.  Prepared   by  ITE  for U.S. Department of Transportation.
Innes, D., Ircha, M.C., and Badoe, D.A. (1990): Factors Affecting Automobile Shopping TripDestinations. Journal of Urban Planning and Development, Vol. 116, No. 3, pp. 126-136.
Jakle, J., and Sculle, K. (2004): Lots of Parking. Charlottesville, University of Virginia Press.
Litman, T. (2006):  Parking  Management  Best  Practices.  Chicago,  American  Planning Association.  
Palmer, D and Ferris, C (2010):  Parking  Measures  and  Policies  Research Review.  Geoff
Dawe, Department for Transport, Transport Research Laboratory.
Shoup, D. (2004): The Ideal Source of Local Public Revenue. Regional Science and Urban Economics, Vol. 34, 2004.
U.S. Department of Transportation (1980): Study of Parking Management Tactics Vol. 1. U.S.A.
U.S. Department of Transportation (1981): Study of Parking Management Tactics Vol. 3. U.S.A.

Thursday, January 8, 2015

ENSURING POPULAR PARTICIPATION AT THE LOCAL LEVEL: A REVIEW OF MMDCEs ELECTION.

1.1 Introduction:
The term governance and good governance form almost part of our daily vocabulary. Governance describes the processes, mechanisms and institutions through which collective decision are made and implemented; citizens, groups and communities pursue their visions, articulate their interests, exercise their legal rights, meet their obligations and mediate their differences (Corlinius Adablah, 2004). The quality of governance is thus determined by the impact of the exercise of power on the quality of life enjoyed by its citizens (Huther and Shah, 1999). Governance, as a dynamic process, has several emphases, and has been defined in literature to encompass local governance, decentralised governance, or democratic governance.

The wisdom of effective participation in the governing of the people by the governor through elective legitimacy was not challenged by society, except by its dictatorial members such as traditional rulers who source their positions from lineage, military rulers who take power by force of arms, or constitutional dictators who are able to manipulate the rule of law (legal and judicial) to entrench themselves in power for too long. To keep the detached rural and local societies under control, the PNDC administration saw to the fashioning out of a local government system that had the District Chief Executive (DCE) unelected, and one-third of the assembly members appointed by government, though the 1992 Constitution provides in Article 240 clause 2, sections (d) and (e). This was as a measure to ensure accountability of “local government authorities”.

Article 243 clauses 1, 2 (c) and 3 (b) did not only render the Constitution internally inconsistent, but also made sure that central government, and by extension the ruling party, and its local agents had manipulative authority and power over the district chief executive, and he or she so recognised that. The local government system in Ghana currently faces setbacks, scores of local government experts and political watchers have shared light on the causes of the seemingly non performance of the decentralized local government bodies. Many have sought to question the mode of selection of Metropolitan, Municipal and District Chief Executive (MMDCE).

On this note, an argument on whether MMDCEs should be appointed by the central government (maintain the status quo) or should be elected by the people at the grassroots (changing the status quo) is presented. Several reasons have been advanced in favour of making the position elective or non elective. This brings us to the bottom line by resolving the issue “MMDCEs should be elected by the people at the grassroots”.




General recommendations have been proposed which could help solve or neutralize all associated outcomes on the subject. The decentralization policy is to ensure a bottom up and participatory development planning approach that can help ensure the active involvement of all stakeholders. In our estimation, if the appointment of MMDCEs to the District Assemblies continues then it would take Ghana several decades to lift the over six million poor Ghanaians out of poverty. It will also continually undermine the country's fledgling democracy. It is therefore appealed to parliament to consider reviewing the relevant sections of the constitution to ensure that the people at the grassroots elect their MMDCEs.

1.2 Decentralisation Reforms:
Decentralization is an “omnibus” word widely used by practising politicians, administrators and academics with many different meanings. However, Rondinelli, Nellis and Cheema (1984) provide one widely accepted definition of decentralization as the transfer of the responsibility for planning, decision making or administrative authority from central government to its field organisations.

In the post-independence period from 1957 onwards, local government was generally weak and subject to the centralization of power that was typical of the post-colonial state. Attempts at decentralizing functions were introduced at different times; for instance in 1974 there was a decentralization reform which was generally characterized by deconcentration, and aimed at strengthening central government control at the local level (Nkrumah 2000).

A historical aspect was the decentralization reforms introduced in between (1981-92). In 1983, there was a policy of administrative decentralization of central government ministries, alongside the creation of People’s Defense Committees (PDCs) in each town and village. The PDCs, made up of local activists as self-identified defenders of the ‘revolution’, effectively took over local government responsibilities, though often limited to mobilizing the implementation of local self-help projects (Nkrumah 2000), while the deconcentrated ministries played a more significant role.

Ayee (2000) noted that around this same period (1981-92), the interest in decentralization reflected that of previous regimes, that is, an interest in the administrative decentralization of central government and not the devolution of political authority to the local level. Additionally, he perceives a key feature of local governance in the pre-1988 period as a dual hierarchical structure in which central and local government institutions “operated in parallel”.

1.3 The Status Quo:
The Local Government Act 462 provides that there shall be a District Chief Executive for each district who shall be appointed by the President with the prior approval of not less than two-thirds majority of the members of the District Assembly present and voting at the meeting. The term of office of a District Chief Executive shall be four years. A person shall not hold office as a District Chief Executive for more than two terms in succession. The emoluments of a District Chief Executive shall be charged on the Consolidated Fund and shall be determined by a committee under article 71 of the Constitution.

The District Chief Executive shall be the chairman of the Executive Committee of the District Assembly. The District Chief Executive shall:
  • Preside at meetings of the Executive Committee of the District Assembly and in his absence a member present from among themselves shall reside;
  • Be responsible for the day-to-day performance of the executive and administrative functions of the Assembly;
  • Be responsible for the supervision of the departments of the Assembly; and
  • Be the chief representative of the Central Government in the district.
The office of the District Chief Executive shall become vacant if:
  • A vote of no confidence, supported by the votes of not less than two-thirds of all the members of the District Assembly, is passed against him; or
  • He is removed from office by the President; or
  • He resigns or dies.
1.4 Arguments for the Election of MMDCEs:
Several reasons have been advanced in favour of making the position elective. The importance of electing MMDCEs by the people at the grassroots includes:

Firstly, it enhances universal acceptability. Under the current dispensation, the president appoints the head of the MMDAs based on partisan politics ground. This tends to breed apathy amongst those at the side of divide. Those who belong to the ruling party see the appointed member as one of their own blood and that the appointed person should adhere to their demands the swiftest. Electing MMDCEs will help solve this bias.

Secondly, when the heads of MMDAs are elected it will help ensure continuity in developmental activities. This is because the elected will be there not to pursue any agenda of a political party which are often selective in terms of scope and area of operation. Under the current non elective mode, MMDCEs may pursue vigorously developmental activities in areas that are loyal or sympathetic to the cause of the governing party of which the District Chief Executive is a member of. This practice sometimes leads to having projects being abandoned.

Thirdly, it helps in curtailing the emergence of “foot soldiers unrest”. What is featuring more prominently in the local government front is the “foot soldiers unrest” which has resulted in handful of political heads of MMDAs losing their job. If the position was elective under no circumstance will some aggrieved members of the ruling party get the nerve to demand the resignation of the elected MMDCEs.

Again, it improves performance. Electing the MMDCEs means they will go to the people regularly to seek or renew their mandate to serve. When that happens (as is the case at the national level) MMDCEs who underperform will be kicked out and new ones brought in to deliver the goods. Agyei-Badu (2006) fully agrees that the MMDCEs should be elected so they can be more accountable to the people, thus the electorates will judge them by their performance. He posited that if they are elected we will depart from the hypocrisy that the MMDCE's position is non-partisan.

1.5 Arguments against the Election of MMDCEs:
A decentralisation expert, Mr Kwamena Ahwoi, has stated that although about 80 per cent of stakeholders in the district assembly concept favour the election of District Chief Executives (DCEs) by the people at the grassroot, he is of a strong conviction that any move towards that would bring anarchy, inefficiency and marginalisation of women. Under this sub section, the reasons why MMDCEs should be appointed and not elected by the people at the grassroot are presented. These reasons are expatiated below:

Firstly, it enhances harmony between the president and the appointee. Some local government analysts posit that once the president has been elected through popular votes, then it means that the entire citizenry at that particular time have bought into his development agenda. These analysts again suggest that the president must be allowed to appoint his able lieutenants in order to execute his developmental agenda. The brain behind this is to ensure harmony, avert the retardation in development and sabotage that may possibly emanate when the elected heads of districts do not see eye with a president due to discrepancies in development agenda.

Secondly, it checks corruption. Even though the current mode of selecting MMDA political heads provide grounds for them to be corrupt, the level of corruption predictably will be worse under an elective mode of selection. All things being equal aspirants who may seek election may invest heavily in campaign after securing the position may think of recouping every pesewa invested thereby breeding corruption.

In addition, it checks ethnic differences. Quite a number of districts in the country are made up of majority and minority ethnic groups and with such local elections, there is the likelihood that those from the majority ethnic groups would always be elected and this would make the minority ethnic group feel marginalised. When this happens, they would begin to agitate to have a district of their own and this will introduce anarchy into the local governance system because the authorities would not be able to meet such demands, especially when such areas did not satisfy the criteria for becoming a district assembly.

1.6 The Bottom Line:
From the previous sections, it can be seen that the affirmative outweighs the negative. Resolved: MMDCEs should be elected by the people at the grassroots. There is the need for a review of the 1992 constitutional on the nomination of  MMDCEs by the President. This calls for few modifications to make the system less political and more of a local based initiative.

Mr Kwesi Jonah (2011), a lecturer at the Political Science Department of the University of Ghana, once said “For people to enter into politics they must be elected and not nominated in order to stop corruption, patronage and other corrupt practices in local governance”. In most cases, our presidents offer the positions of DCEs to people as payback for some service rendered. The offer of DCE jobs as gifts and rewards to political cronies also explains why the district assemblies are so ineffective and inefficient. The only way to change this is to allow the people to choose their MMDCEs. It may not be the most politically expedient thing to do. But it’s what this country needs to make sure that decentralisation concept works for the people.
The MMDAs as presently constituted continue to be hostage to central government through the power of appointment by the President. This is because deepening democracy requires far reaching reforms at the district and municipal level to make them truly an expression of the political will of the people at the grassroots.

If the motive for appointing MMDCEs and some assembly members by the President is to ensure that policies at the district level were consistent with the national ones then it was possible to appoint technical advisers to the assemblies to help in the formulation, implementation and review of policies at the district level. If the current trend continues then it would take Ghana several decades to lift the remaining six million poor Ghanaians out of poverty.

The idea that the elective mode is expensive is not reflective. What is more costly than living development projects abandoned? In Techiman municipality, about 10 percent of development projects were abandoned in 2008 as a result of a change of government. Under the current non elective mode, MMDCEs may pursue vigorously developmental activities in areas that are loyal or sympathetic to the cause of the governing party, making other places vulnerable. The sad story is that sometimes when there is a change of government, these developmental activities become abandoned. When the political heads of MMDAs are elected, continuity in developmental activities will be ensured. This is because they will not pursue any agenda of a political party.

1.7 Recommendation:
In our estimation, it is recommended that the president, in consultation with party executives and other stakeholders of the district should nominate as many as possible eligible persons for the position of the MMDCEs and then the people at the grassroots would cast their votes to elect one nominee for the chief executive position. These nominees should be allowed to campaign within a specified period of time to sell their mission, vision and program outlines to the electorates. The electorates at the grass root will then assess their performance based on their competence and manifesto presentation to elect their MMDCEs.

This also means that various metropolitan, municipal and district coordinating directors must be empowered to hold forth in the interim (as it is inherently but with additional powers) until substantive MMDCEs are elected. This will help to ensure political commitment and loyalty since nominations for such elections will have to be made by president and decentralized office made conterminous with that of the presidency. However, power of impeachment must be left to the people in their respective districts in accordance with the laid down procedures in order to ensure continuity and accountability.

There should be a vetting committee to vet applicants and the vetting process should be made public and possible broadcast on local FM stations to enable electorates to make informed decisions and choices. The determination of the constitution of the vetting committee should be worked out by the Ministry of Local Government which should include experts from within the respective districts. There should also be mechanism in place to check abuse of office and possible removable from office just like in case of the President.

Furthermore, MMDCEs should be elected alongside with District Assembly members and NOT alongside President or MPs. This means the DCEs term of office would overlap that of the President and MPs at any given time. This is likely to minimize the politics of the process.

Again, MMDCEs’ term of office should be same as that of the President at any given time. But unlike the President who can only run for two terms, DCEs should run as many times as possible provided they have the mandate of their people. This would ensure and enhance performance and reduce corruption since MMDCEs know that so long as they perform effectively and efficiently the people’s power would be given to them to govern.

1.8 Conclusion:
The decentralization policy is to ensure a bottom up and participatory development planning approach that can help ensure the active involvement of all stakeholders. In our estimation, if the appointment of MMDCEs to the Assemblies continues then it would take Ghana several decades to lift the remaining six million poor Ghanaians out of poverty. It will also continually undermine the country's fledgling democracy. It is therefore appealed to parliament to consider reviewing the relevant sections of the constitution to ensure that the people at the grassroots elect their MMDCEs.

LIST OF REFERENCES:
  • Ayee, R.A. (1993). Decentralisation and Local Government under the PNDC. Gyimah-Boadi (Ed), Ghana under PNDC rule, CODESRIA, Dakar.
  • Government of Ghana, (1993) Local Government Act 1993 (Act 462) (4th Edition) Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development Publication, Accra.